Stimulus vs. Covid

  • Interesting chart from Jefferies on the US Economy.
  • They crunched the numbers and found that, because of various bits of stimulus more than offsetting falls in compensation, personal income has actually surged in April.
  • Stimulus is of course front-end loaded and, unless extended, this picture likely fades with time.
  • Nevertheless, it is very interesting to see how strong its impact has been.

Mastercard Spend Data

  • Mastercard have updated spending data for the week ending May 7th.
  • Pictured are cross-border volumes.
  • Card not-present (i.e. physically) non-travel continues to grow strongly.
  • Card present growth has bottomed and seeing a bit of improvement due to intra-Europe travel.
  • Looking within borders. US Switched volumes are now -6% YoY from mid -20%s in April.
  • Rest of world also seeing a bit of improvement from -33% at worst point to -19% now.

US Hotel Occupancy

  • Some tiny green-shoots.
  • STR data for 26 April through 2 May 2020 showed slightly higher U.S. hotel occupancy compared with previous weeks.
  • The black line in the chart is 2009 – the worst year for hotels since the Great Depression.
  • “Week-to-week comparisons showed a third consecutive increase in room demand, which provides further hope that early-April was the performance bottom,”
  • TSA (Transport Security Administration) numbers have indeed ticked up and are at the highest level since March 30th.
  • At the same time, this past week was the first to show solid evidence of leisure demand as weekend occupancy grew in states that have significantly eased mitigation efforts.”
  • h/t Calculated Risk.

Covid Impact Update – Location & Other Data

  • We previously highlighted Foursquare location data.
  • Here is the latest update a month on.
  • A lot of traffic is starting to return to normal – fast food, gasoline stations and auto shops have all come back.
  • Indeed fuel demand has started to tick up as well.
  • Spending is also picking up (likely helped by government support).
  • Peaks have normalised in grocery stores and big box retail.
  • One interesting point here is that some food companies have pointed out that buying big multi-packs for stocking vs. single serve has hurt margins (page 6 here).
  • Home improvement stores and outdoor trails are still seeing traffic much higher than February.
  • Bars, restaurants, offices, clothing stores, furniture stores, movie theatres and gyms are still at lows.

Hoisington Q1 2020 Letter

  • Another interesting instalment from Hoisington.
  • Whereas Einhorn thinks that inflation is coming, Hoisington think this couldn’t be further from the truth (and hence think the yield curve will be anchored at zero).
  • Recent articles have suggested that the Federal Reserve and the Department of the Treasury are engaged in Modern Monetary Theory (MMT) or some form of “helicopter money”, the famous Milton Friedman phrase also referred to by Ben Bernanke. The inference is that once the virus is contained, these new efforts will yield different and more powerful economic and inflation results than did the Quantitative Easing periods following the 2008-09 Global Financial Crisis (GFC). Further, the suggestion is that the fiscal policy actions taken this year totaling $2.7 trillion will be far more effective than the $2 trillion stimulus package of 2009. Are these assertions that MMT is in place and monetary and fiscal actions will spur economic and inflation rates higher true? The short answer is no.
  • What follows is a rather technical economic theoretic description of what is going on.
  • It is worth getting one’s head around this. Especially understanding how quantitative easing leads to increased excess deposits by banks at the Fed and not borrowing (a decision that is independent) and hence economic impact.
  • Overall they are predicting deflation – grim reading indeed.

Global Consumer Pulse

  • Nice table from McKinsey on the global consumer.
  • It shows net intent to purchase a particular category by country.
  • Net intent = % who said they would increase purchases in the next two weeks compared to usual minus % who said they wouldn’t.
  • Interesting to see China/Korea recovering somewhat but not in all areas.

Chinese Economic Activity

  • Interestingly surveys suggest Chinese consumers are cautious despite lifting of the lockdown.
  • A Morgan Stanley online survey of 2019 consumers in 19 provinces last week found that while most respondents—86%—were leaving the house for work, most were still reluctant to go out to shop, eat or socialize. And 69% said they would go out for essentials only, down from 75% in early March—still extremely high.” (Source: WSJ).
  • The chart below is also interesting showing how activity across a set of indicators has fared so far in China post the lunar new year as the country opens up.
  • In short – activity will take some time to recover.
  • Could the same be the case in other countries?

Dividend Futures

  • The dividend futures market has been crushed.
  • This chart (from ML) on the left shows the futures curve for S&P 500 dividends compared to 2019.
  • The blue line is how the market looked at the top (21st Jan 2020) and the orange how it looks today.
  • The market is pricing in -42% in dividends by 2021.
  • The right hand side shows the situation in 2008 – the actual reality (dark orange line) was far better.
WordPress Cookie Notice by Real Cookie Banner